• All blog entries
    • Calculators
    • Case studies
    • Cost of living
    • CPF Are You Ready?
    • CPF Matters
    • Credit Management
    • e-Learning
    • Estate Planning
    • Events
    • Financial advisers
    • High Networth
    • Insurance
    • Investments
    • Letters to the Press
    • Magazines
    • Others
    • Retirement Planning
    • Scams
    • Surveys
    • Tragic Stories
    • Unethical sales process
    • Videos
  • Legal
  • Testimonies
    • Individual testimonies
    • Gallery
  • My Account
Hi, looking for a fee-based financial planner in Singapore? Read this article now!
  • Home
  • About
    • About Wilfred Ling
    • Why do you run your own professional financial planning practice?
  • FAQs
    • FAQs on Wilfred Ling’s Financial Services
    • FAQs on Financial Planning
    • FAQs on Investments
    • FAQs on Insurance
    • FAQs on Estate Planning
  • Services
    • Overview
    • Create a financially secure plan for your young family (package details)
    • Retirement Planning
    • Investment Portfolio Management
    • Insurance Planning
  • Fees
  • Cool Tools
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
You are here: Home / Investments / $300m company’s share price sliding down like a falling knife (not referring to Noble)

$300m company’s share price sliding down like a falling knife (not referring to Noble)

28, November 2017 by Wilfred Ling 3 Comments

Last Updated on 20, June 2018

By now, everybody is aware that Noble’s share has been on a decline by a large magnitude. In fact, its share price is down by a whopping 98.43% compared to 5 years ago

Like Noble, there is another company’s share price that has been sliding down. Unlike Noble, we do not hear much in the news of its dismay stock price performance.

Company X4 (clients are to login to see more details) is a well-known company that is worth $300 million in terms of its market capitalization and it is listed on the Singapore Stock Exchange. The total return for the past 5 years was -67% as shown by the blue line in the chart below. On the other hand, the STI’s total return was up 35% over the same period:

What are the reasons why Company X4 is doing so badly?

Profitable but not to shareholders

In the FY2016, its annual report stated that it has a profit of $4.762 million. Normally when we say “profit”, we refer to the profit earned by equity holders. However, Company X4’s equity holders consists of shareholders, preference and perpetual capital securities holders as well. In this case, shareholders rank last in terms of the company’s earnings.

For the FY2016, the company has to pay a whopping $63.8 million to preference and perpetual capital securities holders. Hence, shareholders end up making a loss of $59 million.

Below are the historical profits of the company taken directly from its annual reports. As it can be seen that the profit of the company has been declining over the past years and yet payment to its preference and perpetual capital securities holders have been increasing to the extend that the earnings of the company are insufficient to support such payment.

 2016 S$2015 S$2014 S$2013 S$2012 S$
Profit of the year4,762,00041,273,00057,469,00044,026,00060,994,000
Dividends on perpetual preference/capital shares(63,765,000)(49,650,000)(43,800,000)(24,000,000)(24,000,000)
Profit attributable to ordinary shareholders(59,003,000)(8,377,000)13,669,00020,026,00036,994,000

Negative operating cash flow for years

Another reason for the slide in share price is due to its negative operating cash flow for many years as can be seen below. The company tried hard to support its cash flow by financing but in most years, it simply keeps on burning cash. If this continue, Company X4 has to sell its assets to support its negative cash flow.

 2016 S$2015 S$2014 S$2013 S$2012 S$
Operating cash flow(272,000,000)(43,651,000)(226,133,000)(422,431,000)(243,876,000)
Cash flow from investing(146,106,000)(103,590,000)206,288,000(26,417,000)(34,417,000)
Cash flow from financing383,658,00059,538,000210,188,000168,036,000142,230,000
Net cash flow(34,448,000)87,703,000190,343,000(280,812,000)(136,063,000)

High gearing

Company X4 has a significant high gearing ratio. In fact, if its preference and perpetual capital securities are reclassified as debts, its gearing is even higher. To calculate its leverage, I use debt-to-asset ratio. Debt-to-asset ratio is a more intuitive ratio as it is simply the percentage of the company assets that belongs to creditors. Other types of leverage ratio like debt-to-equity is not intuitive.

In the table below, debt-to-asset is simply the total debts divided by the total assets. On the other hand, the adjusted debt-to-asset is the same ratio except that I reclassify its preference and perpetuals as debts:

 2016 S$2015 S$2014 S$2013 S$2012 S$
Curent Assets1,298,379,000995,505,000838,814,000620,870,000914,916,000
Non-current Assets2,544,954,0002,029,850,0001,902,901,0001,775,635,0001,435,428,000
Current liabilities983,636,000945,869,000390,628,000359,858,000391,792,000
Non-current liabilities1,310,682,000778,635,0001,009,099,0001,150,355,0001,081,523,000
Equity1,549,015,0001,300,851,0001,341,988,000886,292,000877,029,000
Perpetual capital securities785,280,000469,096,000469,096,00000
Perpetual preference shares392,569,000392,569,000392,569,000392,569,000392,569,000
Calculations
Debt-to-asset59.70%57.00%51.05%63.02%62.69%
Adjusted debt-to-asset90.3%85.5%82.5%79.4%79.4%

It can be seen that the gearing ratio has been increasing over the years. Currently, a whopping 90.3% of its assets belongs to creditors!

Conclusions

I pity its shareholders. If they have invested 5 years ago, they would be sitting at a lost of 67%. To add insult to the injury, they would have miss out the opportunity cost of the bull run. If we use the STI as a proxy for the opportunity cost, they would have made gain of 35%. By the way, a loss of 67% requires a gain of 149% just to breakeven.


The following can only be seen by clients:


 

Like this article? Subscribe to my newsletter below for more.

Get regular Tips on Financial Planning. Free subscription for 3 years. Covers all aspect of financial planning such as 'How much salary you should have?', 'How to avoid insurance that is not suitable?", 'What are the retirement planning methods?", etc

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Print

Related

Filed Under: Investments

Comments

  1. Anoyn says

    2, December 2017 at 3:50 am

    2015 S$ Profit should be $52.45m…

    Reply
    • Wilfred Ling says

      4, December 2017 at 9:18 pm

      Thanks. Seems the profit was restated. I was relying on the 2015 annual report. But since an investor has no benefit of future restatement of the report and can only benefit from historical reports, I will leave the figure as it is (i.e. as originally reported).

      Reply
  2. Martin Lee says

    10, January 2018 at 4:21 pm

    Their earnings have been dragged down mainly by Tuaspring and low energy prices.

    Reply

What do you think? Leave a comment. Cancel reply


WILFRED LING, CFA

WANT TO GET REGULAR TIPS ON FINANCIAL PLANNING?

JOIN with thousands of other subscribers in getting tips on all aspect of financial planning such as "What is the minimum salary required?", "How avoid insurance that is not suitable", etc.


WILFRED LING IN THE NEWS

Click HERE to find out more.


THE KIND OF CLIENTS I AM LOOKING FOR

NEW TO US?

Learn how you can fully benefit from this massive website: HERE

For Registered Users Only (free)

  • Webinar on Major change in cancer treatments in your integrated shield plans 3/9/2022
  • How and what to invest now? (Webinar) 28/7/2022
  • How to identify high performing unit trusts in 3 steps (Webinar) 3/9/2021
  • Financial Planning – Christian Perspective Part 2 (Webinar) 14/8/2021
  • How and what to invest now? (Webinar) 22/7/2021

View All

For Clients Only

  • Video Message to Clients 30/12/2021
  • Exclusive client-only Investment Update Webinar by Wilfred 26/11/2021
  • JPMorgan Guide to Market Q2 2020 15/4/2020
  • JPMorgan Perspective Q2 2020 15/4/2020
  • JPMorgan Guide to Market Q1 2020 5/2/2020

View All

Top Posts

  • Strange way of how CPF Interest is calculated & retirement planning CPF has a rather strange way of calculating interest. I...
  • Access Information & Sign Up Page
  • AIA Pro Achiever 2.0 and my recommendations AIA Pro Achiever 2.0 was a product which someone recent...
  • CPF: How to Accumulate $1m in your CPF by 57? I read online that there are people who wants to achiev...
  • Single Premium NTUC Income SAIL The NTUC Income Single premium Sail is now available.  ...

Recent comments

  • Sinkie on What Can You Invest If You Have $400k?
  • Sinkie on Why Vanguard Fund Investors Underperformed The Fund Significantly?
  • Sinkie on Why You Always BUY HIGH In Investments?
  • honest_me on Cancer patient ends up with $33,000 bill after insurer refuses to pay for drug & what you must do to avoid this situation
  • susan on Single Premium NTUC Income SAIL
  • susan on Single Premium NTUC Income SAIL

To be notified of new blog post, like this facebook page

To be notified of new blog post, like this facebook page

Read articles based on different categories

Investment Login

iFAST Central: Login

iFAST Prestige: Login

Navigator: Login

Chartered Financial Analyst

CFA

Chartered Financial Consultant

ChFC

Featured Blogger

IM$avvy

© Copyright 2006-2023 Wilfred Ling

This advertisement or publication has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore

hollow-nasty
hollow-nasty
hollow-nasty
hollow-nasty