• All blog entries
    • Calculators
    • Case studies
    • Cost of living
    • CPF Are You Ready?
    • CPF Matters
    • Credit Management
    • e-Learning
    • Estate Planning
    • Events
    • Financial advisers
    • High Networth
    • Insurance
    • Investments
    • Letters to the Press
    • Magazines
    • Others
    • Retirement Planning
    • Scams
    • Surveys
    • Tragic Stories
    • Unethical sales process
    • Videos
  • Legal
  • Testimonies
    • Individual testimonies
    • Gallery
  • My Account
Hi, looking for a fee-based financial planner in Singapore? Read this article now!
  • Home
  • About
    • About Wilfred Ling
    • Why do you run your own professional financial planning practice?
  • FAQs
    • FAQs on Wilfred Ling’s Financial Services
    • FAQs on Financial Planning
    • FAQs on Investments
    • FAQs on Insurance
    • FAQs on Estate Planning
  • Services
    • Overview
    • Create a financially secure plan for your young family (package details)
    • Retirement Planning
    • Investment Portfolio Management
    • Insurance Planning
  • Fees
  • Cool Tools
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
You are here: Home / Investments / Why this company’s stock price plunged despite large profit announcement?

Why this company’s stock price plunged despite large profit announcement?

30, April 2018 by Wilfred Ling Leave a Comment

Q: Wilfred, Company X5 announced on 8th March 2018 that its full year results for 2017 was US$163 million in earnings. This was significantly larger than that in 2016 of only $6.7 million. However, its stock price plunge by –17.2% since then even taking into account of dividends. Why is this so? The S&P 500 total return during the same period was -2.33%.

Answer:

There could be many reasons. Some are simple and others are complicated. I will attempt to explain in simple terms.

No long-term consistent net income

One reason could be that Company X5 (clients are to login to see the company name) does not have a good track record. Its past earnings were not very consistent. Here is the historical net income. You can see that the large $163 million profit is very unusual compared to the past.

In Millions of USD 12 Months Ending As ReportedNet Income
FY 2008-17.642
FY 2009-35.334
FY 20106.416
FY 201120.937
FY 201224.268
FY 201317.178
FY 20148.217
FY 2015-7.431
FY 20166.663
FY 2017163.052
Source: Bloomberg

Poor cash flow

Its historical cash flow are as follows:

In Millions of USD 12 Months Ending As ReportedTotal Cash Flows From OperationsTotal Cash Flows From InvestingTotal Cash Flows From Financing
FY 200827.511-12.72-14.829
FY 200914.789-3.734-13.108
FY 201027.86-14.459-14.304
FY 201114.955-21.0536.638
FY 201237.358-14.778-9.574
FY 201331.751-15.25-32.291
FY 201430.708-281.608286.973
FY 201533.31-665.838611.851
FY 201669.352-41.224-24.481
FY 2017-59.818282.471-14.251
Source: Bloomberg

In FY 2017, its operating cash flow was -$59.8 million despite having a profit of $163 million. Why is this so? This is because ‘profit’ is merely an accounting term. It does not mean the company actually earns $163 million.  In fact, if you dig deeper, its profit for FY 2017 was mainly due to a gain of $133.67 million due to sale of a business.

Stock Price is Expensive

If you plot the PE ratio, you will see that it is now extremely expensive. Its PE ratio is at 47.12x. The graph shows that its PE ratio suddenly surged somewhere in early 2017 (highlighted in red circle) when the stock price was still rising.

To put it in context, the following is the PE chart for S&P500. It is now at 20.8x PE ratio.

Complicated Explanation

Although the PE ratio is 47.12x, such a ratio is based on historical information. Price is the current price but earnings in the “PE” is based on history. What is important is the future. If say the earnings growth rate is 100%, the PE ratio based on current price becomes 47.12/(1+100%) = 23.6x which is no longer that expensive.

That is why there is an entire industry created to predict the growth rate of companies. At this moment of writing, there are 8 analysts who are following this stock. According to their crystal balls, 4 recommends a ‘buy’ and 3 recommends a ‘hold’ and one recommends a ‘sell’.  Their average prediction for Q1 2018 earnings is -30.4% growth. For Q2 2018 earnings is -34.3% growth. If the stock price does not change and assuming our fortune tellers predict correctly, the PE ratio is going to go up to 47.12/(1-0.304) = 67.7x. Ouch!

Conclusions

  • Profitable companies do not necessary mean they are profitable.
  • Profitable companies do not imply the stock price will go up. At times, it can go down.

Like this article? Subscribe to my newsletter below for more.

Get regular Tips on Financial Planning. Free subscription for 3 years. Covers all aspect of financial planning such as 'How much salary you should have?', 'How to avoid insurance that is not suitable?", 'What are the retirement planning methods?", etc

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Print

Related

Filed Under: Investments

What do you think? Leave a comment. Cancel reply


WILFRED LING, CFA

WANT TO GET REGULAR TIPS ON FINANCIAL PLANNING?

JOIN with thousands of other subscribers in getting tips on all aspect of financial planning such as "What is the minimum salary required?", "How avoid insurance that is not suitable", etc.


WILFRED LING IN THE NEWS

Click HERE to find out more.


THE KIND OF CLIENTS I AM LOOKING FOR

NEW TO US?

Learn how you can fully benefit from this massive website: HERE

For Registered Users Only (free)

  • How and what to invest now? (Webinar) 28/7/2022
  • How to identify high performing unit trusts in 3 steps (Webinar) 3/9/2021
  • Financial Planning – Christian Perspective Part 2 (Webinar) 14/8/2021
  • How and what to invest now? (Webinar) 22/7/2021
  • Financial Planning – Christian Perspective Part 1 (Webinar) 10/7/2021

View All

For Clients Only

  • Video Message to Clients 30/12/2021
  • Exclusive client-only Investment Update Webinar by Wilfred 26/11/2021
  • JPMorgan Guide to Market Q2 2020 15/4/2020
  • JPMorgan Perspective Q2 2020 15/4/2020
  • JPMorgan Guide to Market Q1 2020 5/2/2020

View All

Top Posts

  • Access Information & Sign Up Page
  • Strange way of how CPF Interest is calculated & retirement planning CPF has a rather strange way of calculating interest. I...
  • CPF: How to Accumulate $1m in your CPF by 57? I read online that there are people who wants to achiev...
  • AIA Pro Achiever 2.0 and my recommendations AIA Pro Achiever 2.0 was a product which someone recent...
  • Vanguard funds in Singapore at just US$ 20,000! Vanguard is the world’s most famous index fund provider...

Recent comments

  • Sinkie on Why Vanguard Fund Investors Underperformed The Fund Significantly?
  • Sinkie on Why You Always BUY HIGH In Investments?
  • honest_me on Cancer patient ends up with $33,000 bill after insurer refuses to pay for drug & what you must do to avoid this situation
  • susan on Single Premium NTUC Income SAIL
  • susan on Single Premium NTUC Income SAIL
  • LittleTiger on Nomination in insurance policies

To be notified of new blog post, like this facebook page

To be notified of new blog post, like this facebook page

Read articles based on different categories

Investment Login

iFAST Central: Login

iFAST Prestige: Login

Navigator: Login

Chartered Financial Analyst

CFA

Chartered Financial Consultant

ChFC

Featured Blogger

IM$avvy

© Copyright 2006-2022 Wilfred Ling

This advertisement or publication has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore

hollow-nasty
hollow-nasty
hollow-nasty
hollow-nasty